Skip to main content

Book Review: The Seven Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle by Stuart Turton

 The Seven Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle 

By Stuart Turton 

 Goodreads Link


Published Year: 2018 

Page count : 445 pages 

Medium Used : Kindle Paperwhite 

Genre : Suspense,Whodunit, Novel Concept,  Science Fiction, Mystery, 2024-read. 

Rating : 3.40/5 😀😀😀




Story Outline 

Its a game. Its a game that is an endless loop, designed to solve a murder mystery. A young girl is reunited with her family after 19 years. A party is thrown to a group of people and she is murdered on the day at 11PM by someone and for some motive unknown. The game rules that those who participate in it should solve the murder and the first person who unravels it gets to leave the game. Three people are participants in it. Anna, Daniel Coleridge and Aiden Bishop. What's more interesting is that they can solve it by embodying a different personality each day for eight days. Only Aiden can do it and the other two just have one body to stick to. So Aiden can see the same day of murder from within the bodies of eight guests and use their position, their deductive skills along with his unrelenting tenacity to solve it. He vows to release not only himself but also Anna. He vows to get out of this game by beating the footman who is chasing to kill them and end each loop. He vows to demystify the person who has put them through this game and get out of it. 


My First Opinion 

I feel this story has become too complex and convoluted to really follow and untangle the mystery. I think the author botched the script a bit. This is his debut novel and that shows. The concept is novel and great. The prose is good, the characters are well portrayed and the ending twist is an absolute gut punch, knock out. But i think he put more emphasis on certain things like the multiple personalities and what is happening to whom, when and how to escape from the footman, that the mystery of who murdered Evelyn Hardcastle becomes sidetracked. It is difficult while reading to keep track of all the stuff going on .. reading shouldn't be so hard right? I guess on a second or third read of the book, one would know what pieces are important and what are not, which to remember and which to discard instead of trying to cram everything or breezing over everything.  


Its a nice read. A warm and cozy read with a cup of hot tea or ☕ coffee. But on the whole, I think it could have been better written or well done. The idea is stunning to say the least. To use people like Anna and Daniel along with Aiden in solving mysteries that were unsolved is novel and a very useful suggestion. But perhaps even the intention is overlooking certain flaws like what if this experiment,  instead of changing a bad person for the better, pushes a sane mind into madness and endless cruelty? Because they can do anything to just get out of the game right? 



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Thorn Birds by Colleen McCullough book review

The Thorn Birds  By Colleen McCullough  Rating 3.75/5 Genres : Australia, Vatican city, Cardinal, Romance, Generational fiction, Historical fiction  Bah. I dont know. I felt this is just an ok sort of book. The only aspect that stirred me and struck a chord with me is the all encompassing, soul level love between Maggie and Father Ralph de Bricassart. Everything else - no matter how juicy,emotional or dramatic just failed to make an impact. The story covers the lives of three generations of women of the Cleary/Armstrong family line - their cherished dreams and dashed hopes, their hurts and heartbreaks over unrequited, failed loves..their finally getting what they wanted but it not being fully enough.. well, it sounds and feels like a roller coaster.  And whats more..there is plenty of repeat in the events of their lives..what has happened to the mother, happens to the daughter and so on..  Coming to the story. Maggie Cleary is brought up with a ...

Book Review : The Perfect Couple by Elin Hilderbrand

 The Perfect Couple  By Elin Hildebrand  (Nantucket #3) Published Year : 2018 Page Count: 347 pages  Medium Used: Kindle PW  Genre : Romance, Mystery, Suspense, Psychological Thriller, Drama, Crime, 2024-read.  Rating : 4/5  The ending is such an anticlimax and a let down for me - it almost feels like being cheated. I got so high and invested in the narrative..I lost sleep for most of last night and was reading all day since I got up this morning. The character development is ooof .. the characters are filled with life, credulity and fly off the page into the reader's mind space. I loved the layout of the narrative. I loved the writing.  I would have liked if the mother of the family was a bit on the negative side as well. I mean, really, having Nicole Kidman play the role and making it all cute, nice and kind, compassionate is like wasting enormous talent. I picked this book because I saw an ad that there is a limited series coming up on Netflix ...

Book Review: Gideon The Ninth by Tamsyn Muir

 Gideon the Ninth  By Tamsin Muir  Published Year: 2019 Page Count: 448 pages  Medium Used: Kindle PW  Genre : Action, Fantasy, Magic, Necromancers, Adventure, Murder Mystery, Suspense, Lesbian, 2024-read.  Rating : 4.75/5 🙂🙂🙂🙂🌟 Wow. The twists!! And wow wow wow .. the lies!! The deceptions ! Its exotic and steamy! Unputdownable. Highly Addictive. Been wanting to read this for a while now! The paperbacks being so expensive, I settled in for a Kindle experience. I am not disappointed. The lack of smut - which I expected/anticipated when I heard its lesbian fantasy - is such a relief. The tone of the narrator is serious throughout. I had some laugh out loud moments once or twice but that's it. One of the best fantasy book series ever!  I think it is the prose and writing style that I had to read this book real slow so as not to miss anything out. There is action in this book , necromancer magic, fantastic games and there are murders to solve and lyc...